6 Comments
User's avatar
Gillian Richmond's avatar

Such a sad story. Thank you for letting it into the light.

Expand full comment
Caroline Rance's avatar

Thank you, Gillian. I try to do a little bit to acknowledge people who would otherwise be forgotten.

Expand full comment
Lori Olson White's avatar

Another look behind the curtains of society. Fabulous storytelling and such seamless stitching of research and narrative.

Expand full comment
Caroline Rance's avatar

Thank you so much, Lori!

Expand full comment
Viviane Morrigan's avatar

Thank you, Caroline, for an account that is extraordinary. I am left wondering why the death of her sister triggered moving the other sister to a poorhouse? Was the one remaining sister no longer of interest to the doctors of the mind who had been attending them?

Expand full comment
Caroline Rance's avatar

I don’t know what the thinking was behind the move, and the annual report mentioning Marion’s death doesn’t shed any light. Perhaps Catherine’s behaviour changed enough for the Gartnavel doctors to say she had improved and offload her to the poorhouse. I hope I will eventually find out through further research. Thanks so much for reading and commenting!

Expand full comment